February 7, 2013 Data on the rates of environmental compliance can be confusing. State and federal regulators are now using new graphical tools – so-called “Dashboards” – to show compliance rates with environmental laws.
MPCA Grades Minnesota Businesses “A-“, EPA Grades Out as “C” and “Incomplete”
So how are Minnesota’s businesses doing? Well, it depends on whom you talk to.
The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s (“MPCA’s”) Dashboard, which is featured prominently on the MPCA’s website, gives businesses a big thumbs up and a pat on the back noting compliance rates in air quality (92%), water quality (99%) and land (98%), respectively. http://www.pca.state.mn.us/index.php/about-mpca/mpca-news/featured-stories/visualize-progress-mpcas-dashboard.html According to the MPCA, which summarizes data on a single slide in its Dashboard, permit holders are making “good progress” on compliance measures.
By contrast, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) using the same MPCA data and much more detailed data of its own, shows decidedly mixed results and much lower rates of compliance than those claimed by the MPCA. http://www.epa-echo.gov/echo/stateperformance/dashboard.php?state=Minnesota&media=waste The EPA Dashboard feature tracks a wider range of metrics within separate categories of facilities, compliance evaluations, violations, high priority violations, enforcement actions and penalties. The EPA data appears to indicate a higher level of violations or noncompliance than that noted by the MPCA. For example, according to the EPA 60.2% of Minnesota’s major facilities with water quality permits were in noncompliance in 2012. Ninety nine of the one hundred and nine facilities that were inspected had violations.
To receive www.enviroattorney.net blog updates and posts, we invite you to subscribe by providing your e-mail address at the space at the top of this page.
Please see the disclaimer at the bottom of this page that relates to limitations on this blog and to legal advice.